Love Island All Stars viewers were left cringing after Scott embraced his inner Clueless teen Cher Horowitz during Sunday’s show.
During a game of Suck and Blow the hunk, 36, revealed his attraction to new bombshell Tina, 29, leaving India, 34, with whom he is coupled up seething with jealously.
When she later accused him of being the ‘most calculated’ in the villa, a furious Scott declared she’d well and truly ‘given him the ick’.
Fans at home were left bemused his turn of phrase, which was made popular in 1995 teen comedy Clueless, and exclaimed: ‘You are nearly 40!’.
Taking to X they fumed: ’36 year old Scott using the word ‘ick’ is an ick in itself’: ‘”She’s given me the ick bro” you too damn old Scott’: ‘Using the word ick… Scott you are in your THIRTIES’: ‘Scott is 36 and using the term “ick”‘: ‘Scott throwing the word ‘ick’ around is giving me the ick. A nearly 40 year old man saying ick. I’m ᴅᴇᴀᴅ. India’s too good for you mate’.
Elsewhere during the racy game Elma Pazar was quick to take a swipe at Ronnie Vint’s ex Harriett Blackmore.
Love Island All Stars viewers were left cringing after Scott, 36, embraced his inner Clueless teen Cher Horowitz during Sunday’s show
During a game of Suck and Blow he revealed his attraction to new bombshell Tina, 29, leaving India, 34, with whom he is coupled up seething with jealously (1995’s Clueless pictured)
The game saw the stars tasked with carrying a card around the group using their mouths, and whoever the card dropped on, had to answer a truth, or complete a dare.
With Ronnie the unlucky recipient during one round, he chose Truth, and was asked which two girls he’d love to see return to the villa.
Elma, who herself has endured a turbulent romance with Ronnie, quipped: ‘Well he’s not going to say Harriet is he?’
Ronnie had previously dated Harriett during their time in the Love Island villa last year, but split in September, amid cheating claims.
Elma’s comment left many fans in hysterics, with one declaring that six months after appearing on the show, Harriett was still ‘living rent-free in everyone’s heads.’
Posts on X included: ‘The girls continuously mentioning Harriett;’
‘The random Harriett mention… her return looms;’
‘Not Elma mentioning Harriett; He’s not going to say Harriett is he” HAHAHAHAHA.’
When she later accused him of being the ‘most calculated’ in the villa, a furious Scott declared she’d well and truly ‘given him the ick’
Fans at home were left bemused his strange turn of phrase, which was made popular in 1995 teen comedy Clueless, and exclaimed: ‘You are nearly 40!’ (India pictured)
Alicia Silverstone (R) and Stacey Dash (L) pictured in Clueless
Taking to X they fumed: ’36 year old Scott using the word ‘ick’ is an ick in itself’: ‘”She’s given me the ick bro” you too damn old Scott’
Elsewhere in Sunday’s episode, Scott Thomas got a newfound ick for his partner India Reynolds before Tina Stinnes left him blushing.
Read More Love Island: All Stars’ Elma Pazar takes a savage swipe at Ronnie Vint’s ex Harriett Blackmore – leaving fans joking she’s ‘living rent-free in everyone’s heads’ 
During a game of truth or dare, India was asked: ‘Who do you think the most calculated in here is?’
‘After this evening I’m gonna actually go you,’ she says to Scott – leaving him baffled.
He asks: ‘After this evening? What have I done?’
Elma Pazar jogged Scott’s memory explaining that he kissed India in bed before telling her he wanted to get to know Tina.
Scott responded: ‘Seriously? That’s just give me the ick mate… big.’
Scott’s later caught up with Tina, who wanted to make her thoughts clear, telling him: ‘I think we did have the best date…
Elsewhere during the racy game Elma Pazar was quick to take a swipe at Ronnie Vint’s ex Harriett Blackmore
With Ronnie the unlucky recipient during one round, he chose Truth, and was asked which two girls he’d love to see return to the villa
Ronnie had previously dated Harriett during their time in the Love Island villa last year, but they split in September, amid cheating claims
‘I feel comfortable with you and we get along really well and there’s a big attraction there if I was on the outside I’d be like, ‘Oh I wanna kiss you’.’
‘Well I appreciate that,’ Scott said, adding: ‘F****ng hell, I’m blushing!’
But the next morning it was clear Scott still had India on his mind as they had a chat saying: ‘Sorry I’ve been a bit quiet today…
‘I apologise for how I reacted in the heat of the moment,’ with the pair deciding to end things amicably.
LOVE ISLAND: ALL STARS LINE UP 
GABBY ALLEN
AGE: 32
SERIES 3 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Because it’s the trenches out there! I feel like I have all my ducks in a row, it has been 8 years since I went into the Villa. I now run my businesses and I’ve grown up a lot… but I just haven’t found ‘the one’ yet.
KAZ CROSSLEY
AGE: 29
SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
The first experience I had was so amazing and also so much fun! I’m even more mature now so I’m ready to find a relationship.
SCOTT THOMAS
AGE: 36
SERIES 2 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I’ve been on a mᴀssive journey over the last five years; I’ve been working on sobriety, personal growth, self development, when I first went into the Villa I was still a bit of a boy.
RONNIE VINT
AGE: 28
SERIES 11 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I learnt so much from my experience last time. In the Villa I was always in ‘triangles’ and what not, but I feel like I’ve grown up a lot.
LUCA BISH
AGE: 25
SERIES 8 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I had such a good time last time, why not? I get to have a good time with the possibility of ending up with someone.
MARCEL SOMERVILLE
AGE: 39
SERIES 3 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I thought that I’d completed love and found my happily ever after – but the universe had a different plan. Somehow every time my life’s at a crossroads, I’ve got the opportunity to do Love Island. So I thought, why not?
CASEY O’GORMAN
AGE: 28
SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND AND LOVE ISLAND ALL STARS SERIES 1
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Getting to go in within the first few days of the show, I feel like I’ve got such a big opportunity to find someone and hopefully come out of the Villa potentially with a girlfriend.
TINA STINNES
AGE: 29
SERIES 2 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
It was the best experience that I’ve ever had, it made me learn about myself and grow.
CURTIS PRITCHARD
AGE: 28
SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I feel like I’m in a different stage in my life. The idea of settling down is a serious idea in my life right now. I haven’t found my true love.
Nas will be entering the villa almost a year after splitting from girlfriend Eva Zapico four years after they met in the villa
NAS MAJEED
AGE: 28
SERIES 6 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
It was so much fun the first time around, waking up every day with a smile on my face – it feels like a full circle moment.
OLIVIA HAWKINS
AGE: 29
SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I’m still single and getting close to my thirties, I feel ready for it now. I’m ready to meet a nice man. People misinterpret my honesty and how real I am.
CATHERINE AGBAJE
AGE: 24
SERIES 10 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I want to find love again, I want to give it another sH๏τ because it works!
INDIA REYNOLDS
AGE: 34
SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I’ve been single for two and a half years and I think it’s time to settle down.
I don’t put any effort into dating and I don’t really like meeting people from apps so I’m looking forward to getting to know people in the Villa.
ELMA PAZAR
AGE: 32
SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I want to have fun and I want to give it a proper go this time. My time was cut short the first time round and who knows, I could be the next Sophie (Piper) and Josh (Ritchie) or Molly (Smith) and Tom (Clare).
Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu
AGE: 30
SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I want to return to Love Island again because it’s where my journey started and has a special place in my heart. It’s somewhere I’ve laughed, cried and learnt so much. The fact that there’s an opportunity to do it again – why not!
