Love Island: All Stars viewers were left saying the same thing after Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman decided to ‘close off’ their relationship during Sunday’s show.

During their romantic date the pair decided to make things official, but those watching at home were left unconvinced it would be happy ever after. 

After receiving the text the lovebirds left the villa for a candlelight dinner where they confessed their feelings for each other. 

However viewers claimed things wouldn’t last and were fearful for Gabby, 33,  claiming she was clearly more interested in Casey , 28, than he was in her. 

Taking to X they wrote: ‘I give Casey and Gabby a few months max’: ‘I just don’t know if I believe in Gabby and Casey, he is sooo nonchalant and she is sooo anxiously attached’: ‘Something is off with Gabby and Casey. it’s so obvious Gabby is into Casey more than he is into her’. 

‘Closed off at Gabby and Casey’s age…. anyway!’: ‘I’m sorry I just don’t buy Casey and Gabby’: ‘Gabby hasn’t explored her options enough ‘Not like there’s anyone else she could couple up with in there) Casey’s track record, he’s going to break her heart’.

Love Island viewers were left saying the same thing after Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman decided to ‘close off’ their relationship during Sunday’s show

During their romantic date the pair decided to make things official, but those watching at home were left unconvinced it would be happy ever after

After receiving the text the lovebirds left the villa for a candlelight dinner where they confessed their feelings for each other

It comes after Friday’s episode saw the villa waving goodbye to two of the messiest bombshells yet as a recoupling led to Samie Elishi and Danielle Sellers exit the show.

After a messy game of Snog, Marry Pie dominated the evening, the islanders thought they had seen enough drama for 24 hours, but the villa had other ideas in store for them.

The 14 islanders were soon called to gather around the firepit shorty after waking up and the boys were tasked with choosing who they wanted to couple with.

As the last man standing for the recoupling, Chuggs Wallis, 26, was left to choose between Tina Stinnes, Samie, 24, and Danielle, 29, who had previously been coupled with and took on a date.

But after the romance between Chuggs and Danielle did not go plain sailing after the blonde bombshell rejected his kiss after a romantic vineyard date, the islander decided to get his revenge and pick Tina for his new couple.

 And while Danielle had only been a resident in the villa for 10 days and Samie had half of that time, they did not hold back in their entrances as they both gunned for the two strongest couples in the villa during their time.  

When first entering the villa, Danielle immediately hit it off with Curtis Pritchard and got flirty in the hideaway despite him stating he was previously closed off with Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu.

Unphased by Ekin-Su’s territorial behaviour, Danielle continued to pull Curits for chats were he continued his putting his flirtatious charm to the test.

However viewers claimed things wouldn’t last and were fearful for Gabby, 33, claiming she was clearly more interested in Casey , 28, than he was in her

Taking to X they wrote: ‘I give Casey and Gabby a few months max’: ‘I just don’t know if I believe in Gabby and Casey, he is sooo nonchalant and she is sooo anxiously attached’

And while Danielle got to chose her man and steal him from Ekin-Su in a recouple – a move which Curtis did not reject – he was later forced to make a more concrete decision in another recoupling just days later.

Looking torn, Curtis eventually made up his mind and decided to not be tempted by someone who he claimed he had ‘so much in common with’ and chose to stick with Ekin-Su.

Read More Love Island viewers are left divided over Grace Jackson’s reaction to Luca Bish kissing Samie Elishi

Since then, Danielle had struggled to form a connection in the villa and despite being coupled with Chuggs- a decision made by the public – she did not last more than 9 days in the villa.

And Samie also entered the villa with that same fiery energy and gunned for Luca Bish who was in a secure coupling with Grace Jackson.

Samie targetted Luca for the couple as the two had history on the outside.

Luca reportedly messaged Samie on social media when she was in a relationship but she ignored his message because she was in a relationship.

Samie claimed Luca then deleted his message and tried again soon after her latest breakup.

The bombshell also ignored this message because she did not feel ready.

But when she eventually offered Luca the chance to get to know her, he became overwhelmed over the decision because he ‘already had something good with Grace’.

On Friday the villa waved goodbye to two of the messiest bombshells yet as a recoupling saw Samie Elishi (left) and Danielle Sellers (second in from the right) exit the show

After a messy evening throwing pies in each others faces, the islanders thought they had seen enough drama for 24 hours but the villa had other ideas in store for them

Despite being coupled with Samie by the public and going on a date together alongside Chuggs and Danielle in a romantic vineyard setup, Luca stayed reserved and did not entertain Samie’s advances.  

But his stressed reaction did not settle well with Grace and she did not take his response lightly and ensured Samie was out of the picture following Luca’s decision to kiss Samie in a game of Spin The Bottle.

Grace told Luca that he was focusing his efforts on her and to close off any form of interest – a decision that left a sour taste in Samie’s mouth as she later decided to get her revenge and pie him in a game of Snog, Marry, Pie.

But despite their efforts, both Danielle and Samie had to say goodbye to their love interests after they were the only two girls left single in the villa.

LOVE ISLAND: ALL STARS LINE UP

GABBY ALLEN 

AGE:  32

 SERIES 3 LOVE ISLAND

 Why do you want to return to Love Island?

Because it’s the trenches out there! I feel like I have all my ducks in a row, it has been 8 years since I went into the Villa. I now run my businesses and I’ve grown up a lot… but I just haven’t found ‘the one’ yet.

 KAZ CROSSLEY

AGE: 29 

 SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND

 Why do you want to return to Love Island?

The first experience I had was so amazing and also so much fun! I’m even more mature now so I’m ready to find a relationship. 

SCOTT THOMAS

AGE: 36

SERIES 2 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I’ve been on a mᴀssive journey over the last five years; I’ve been working on sobriety, personal growth, self development, when I first went into the Villa I was still a bit of a boy.

 

RONNIE VINT

AGE: 28

SERIES 11 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I learnt so much from my experience last time. In the Villa I was always in ‘triangles’ and what not, but I feel like I’ve grown up a lot.

LUCA BISH

AGE: 25

SERIES 8 LOVE ISLAND 

Why do you want to return to Love Island? 

I had such a good time last time, why not? I get to have a good time with the possibility of ending up with someone. 

CASEY O’GORMAN

AGE: 28

SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND AND LOVE ISLAND ALL STARS SERIES 1

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

Getting to go in within the first few days of the show, I feel like I’ve got such a big opportunity to find someone and hopefully come out of the Villa potentially with a girlfriend. 

TINA STINNES

AGE: 29

SERIES 2 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island? 

It was the best experience that I’ve ever had, it made me learn about myself and grow. 

MONTEL MCKENZIE

AGE: 27

SERIES 10 LOVE ISLAND

Why did you want to return to Love Island?

I want to find love and Love Island is the best environment to find that. 

CURTIS PRITCHARD

AGE: 28

SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?  

I feel like I’m in a different stage in my life. The idea of settling down is a serious idea in my life right now. I haven’t found my true love.

Nas will be entering the villa almost a year after splitting from girlfriend Eva Zapico four years after they met in the villa 

NAS MAJEED

AGE: 28

SERIES 6 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

It was so much fun the first time around, waking up every day with a smile on my face – it feels like a full circle moment.

 CATHERINE AGBAJE

AGE: 24

SERIES 10 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I want to find love again, I want to give it another sH๏τ because it works!

 ELMA PAZAR

AGE: 32

SERIES 5 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I want to have fun and I want to give it a proper go this time. My time was cut short the first time round and who knows, I could be the next Sophie (Piper) and Josh (Ritchie) or Molly (Smith) and Tom (Clare).

Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu

AGE: 30

SERIES 8 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I want to return to Love Island again because it’s where my journey started and has a special place in my heart. It’s somewhere I’ve laughed, cried and learnt so much. The fact that there’s an opportunity to do it again – why not!

GRACE JACKSON

AGE: 26

SERIES 11 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island? 

I feel like at this time in my life I’m in a very settled place. I know who I am and I’m at the age where I’ve had enough of my single years. I’ve done everything I wanted to do in my single life and I’m looking to settle down and create a nice life with someone. What better place to do it than in the Villa?

RON HALL

AGE: 27

SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND

Why do you want to return to Love Island?

I know it works from last time, I was a success story from it, I found love. Obviously it didn’t last, but, if it can happen again, great. 

HARRIETT BLACKMORE

AGE: 24

SERIES 11 LOVE ISLAND

Why did you want to return to Love Island?

I think that my last time in the Villa was cut too short so I think I deserve a second chance, I’m looking forward to it!